Exploring Bands Formed by All but One Member of a Previous Band
Band breakups can often lead to surprising musical reunions and new beginnings. These situations arise from a variety of reasons, including creative differences, personal conflicts, or simply the natural evolution of artists. In many instances, it’s common for most members of a band to part ways with one individual while choosing to continue making music together. This article highlights some notable bands that fit this unique scenario.
Understanding the Dynamics of Band Breakups
When a band disbands, the reasons can vary widely. Sometimes it’s a single event that triggers the split, while other times, it’s a culmination of ongoing tensions. In many cases, one member might not mesh well with the rest, leading to a situation where the remaining members decide to forge ahead without them. It’s essential to recognize that these breakups often stem from complex dynamics rather than any singular fault.
Criteria for Inclusion
To clarify the criteria for the bands featured in this article, we present an example that meets the description and one that does not. For instance, New Order fits perfectly into this category. Following the tragic death of Ian Curtis, the remaining members of Joy Division chose to continue their musical journey under a new name, New Order. They carried on with the same lineup minus Curtis.
Conversely, while Velvet Revolver may seem like a fitting example at first glance, it does not qualify. Members Slash, Duff McKagan, and Matt Sorum formed Velvet Revolver after departing from Guns N’ Roses, but they did not include any of their previous rhythm guitarists. Instead, they enlisted Dave Kushner, who had no prior association with GN’R, along with Scott Weiland of Stone Temple Pilots.
Notable Bands Featuring All but One Member
Here’s a list of bands that successfully continued their musical legacy with all but one member of their previous group:
1. New Order
As mentioned earlier, New Order emerged from the ashes of Joy Division after Ian Curtis’s passing, allowing the remaining members to explore new musical directions.
2. The Police
After the disbandment of The Police, only drummer Stewart Copeland continued to work with guitarist Andy Summers and bassist Sting in various capacities, leading to side projects that showcased their chemistry.
3. Audioslave
Formed by members of Rage Against the Machine—Tom Morello, Tim Commerford, and Brad Wilk—Audioslave included Chris Cornell of Soundgarden, effectively leaving out lead vocalist Zack de la Rocha.
4. The Good, The Bad & The Queen
This supergroup features members of Blur and The Clash, but notably omits Blur’s lead vocalist Damon Albarn, opting instead for a different musical exploration with a unique sound.
5. The Traveling Wilburys
This legendary supergroup included Bob Dylan, George Harrison, Jeff Lynne, and Roy Orbison, while notably leaving out Tom Petty, who was also a prominent figure in rock music at the time.
6. The New Yardbirds (Led Zeppelin)
When the Yardbirds disbanded, three of its members—Jimmy Page, John Paul Jones, and Robert Plant—formed a new band with drummer John Bonham, effectively moving forward without the original group’s lead vocalist.
7. Black Country, New Road
After the departure of Isaac Wood, the remaining members of this British band decided to carry on, showcasing their musical versatility without their original lead vocalist.
8. The Chemical Brothers
Originally part of the duo known as The Dust Brothers, Ed Simons and Tom Rowlands continued their journey as The Chemical Brothers, leaving behind their previous identity but retaining their collaborative spirit.
9. The Raconteurs
Jack White and Brendan Benson formed The Raconteurs after their previous projects, leaving out members from their original bands, allowing them to explore a fresh sound together.
Conclusion
Band dynamics can be unpredictable, leading to fascinating outcomes when members choose to continue without one of their own. The examples above illustrate how creativity can flourish even in the face of separation. By forming new bands with all but one member, these musicians have demonstrated resilience and a dedication to their art, ensuring that their musical legacy lives on in new and exciting ways.
FAQs
What are the common reasons for band breakups?
Common reasons include creative differences, personal conflicts, and changing musical directions. Sometimes, it’s simply a matter of members wanting to pursue individual projects.
How does a band typically decide to continue after a breakup?
Members often discuss their desire to keep making music together and weigh the potential of forming a new project without the departing member.
Are there famous examples of bands that reunited after a breakup?
Yes, many bands have reunited after a breakup, such as Fleetwood Mac, The Eagles, and Guns N’ Roses, often leading to successful tours and new albums.
Can former band members collaborate in new projects?
Absolutely! Former members often collaborate on side projects, supergroups, or guest appearances, allowing them to maintain musical connections.
