Brand New Announces Reunion Shows Amid Controversy

Brand New has officially announced a trio of reunion shows, marking their first public performances since 2017. As excitement builds among fans, discussions on social media reveal a spectrum of opinions regarding the band’s return, particularly in light of past allegations against frontman Jesse Lacey.

The Band’s Hiatus and Controversial Past

Brand New has been largely inactive since 2017, a decision solidified during a live show when Lacey announced the band would disband the following year. This announcement came just two months after the release of their critically acclaimed album, Science Fiction.

In November 2017, following Lacey’s breakup announcement, allegations of sexual misconduct surfaced, including claims of soliciting nude photos from minors. Lacey addressed these allegations in a lengthy Facebook post, apologizing for his behavior and discussing his struggles with sex addiction and infidelity.

In his statement, Lacey expressed remorse for the pain he caused, particularly to women who deserved respect and honesty. He acknowledged the power dynamics that influenced interactions between him and fans, admitting to a pattern of mistreatment.

Following this tumultuous period, Brand New withdrew from the public eye, with only whispers of a potential reunion emerging in late 2024 after the band played a private charity event in Nashville. Lacey’s recent solo performance, where he debuted new material, further fueled speculation about the band’s revival.

Fan Reactions to the Reunion Announcement

The announcement of Brand New’s reunion has sparked a polarized response among fans on social media. Some express anger and disappointment over Lacey’s return, citing the serious nature of the allegations against him.

Voices of Dissent

Critics have taken to platforms like X (formerly Twitter) to voice their disapproval. One user remarked, “I just do not think anything Brand New ever made is good enough to disregard victims of pedophilia and sexual abuse.” Others echoed similar sentiments, emphasizing the importance of holding artists accountable for their actions.

Comments such as “Finding out Brand New is officially back just ruined my day” reflect the dismay felt by some fans, while others cautioned against engaging with discussions about the band on platforms like Reddit, suggesting that the conversations can become overwhelmingly negative.

Mixed Feelings Among Fans

Despite backlash, many fans are experiencing mixed emotions. Some feel conflicted, grappling with their love for Brand New’s music while acknowledging the troubling past of its frontman. Comments like “Brand New is back. Weird,” illustrate the complex feelings surrounding the reunion.

A Welcoming Response

On the flip side, there are fans who express excitement and a willingness to forgive, viewing the reunion as an opportunity for redemption. A fan on X exclaimed, “My favorite band of all time, Brand New, is back!!!!!” celebrating the unexpected news of their return. Similarly, Reddit users shared their joy, with comments like “This is beautiful. I hope it’s just the beginning,” highlighting the emotional connection many still feel towards the band.

Conclusion

Brand New’s reunion has ignited a complex conversation about art, accountability, and the capacity for forgiveness within fan communities. As they prepare to take the stage once again, the band will undoubtedly face ongoing scrutiny and mixed reactions from their audience. Whether this marks a new chapter for Brand New or serves as a reminder of their controversial past remains to be seen.

FAQs

Why has Brand New been inactive since 2017?

Brand New has been inactive since 2017 following allegations of sexual misconduct against lead singer Jesse Lacey, which emerged shortly after he announced the band’s breakup.

What did Jesse Lacey say about the allegations?

Lacey issued a public apology addressing the allegations, admitting to behavior that harmed others and discussing his struggles with sex addiction and infidelity.

What are fans saying about the reunion shows?

Fan reactions to the reunion have been mixed, with some expressing excitement and others voicing disappointment and anger over Lacey’s return to the stage.

When are the reunion shows scheduled?

The specific dates and locations for the reunion shows have been announced, but fans are eagerly awaiting further details on ticket sales and concert logistics.