Fan Reactions to Megadeth’s Cover of Metallica’s “Ride the Lightning”
With the release of Megadeth’s self-titled final album, fans have eagerly responded to the band’s new rendition of Metallica’s iconic track “Ride the Lightning.” This cover, which serves as the closing song on the album, has sparked a variety of reactions among the Metal community.
Background on the Cover
Dave Mustaine, the frontman of Megadeth, had hinted at including a “cover song” on the album before the announcement of it being their last. After teasing the track list over several days, it was revealed that “Ride the Lightning,” a song Mustaine co-wrote during his time with Metallica, would be featured. Mustaine described this cover as a way of “completing the circle,” paying homage to the band that kickstarted his songwriting career.
“That was the beginning of my songwriting career… So doing ‘Ride the Lightning,’ it was kind of completing the circle,” Mustaine explained to Loudwire Nights. He expressed admiration for Metallica’s members, specifically highlighting James Hetfield’s guitar prowess and Lars Ulrich’s unique songwriting style.
Fan Reactions on Reddit
Mixed Reviews
The reception on Reddit has been varied, with fans sharing their thoughts on the cover. One enthusiastic fan noted, “I literally just finished listening to that song. I really liked it as a cover; it sounds like Megadeth from the early years. If I didn’t know the original song existed, I’d be like, ‘Holy shit that was amazing,’ but as much as I liked it, if I ask someone to play ‘Ride the Lightning’ and they put this version on, I’d look at them like the black snake moan meme.”
A Tribute to Metal History
Another Reddit user acknowledged the mixed feelings among fans but argued that the cover is an important tribute. They stated, “This one seemed like an honest tribute. They kept the opening harmonies, which were written by Cliff [Burton] and Lars, and the solos are pretty faithful to what Kirk [Hammett] did. Mustaine let Teemu [Mantysaari] take care of a good part of the leads here.” They concluded, “I believe it now that I’ve heard it. This is metal history.”
Criticism of the Cover
Not all feedback has been positive. Some fans expressed disappointment with the cover’s execution. One commented, “The vocals do not work, and it just sounds like any band could’ve covered it.” Another echoed these sentiments, questioning the need for a note-for-note rendition, saying, “I’m most upset that it’s a note-for-note cover. Why cover a song at this point in your career if you don’t inject your own sound into it?”
Responses on X (Formerly Twitter)
Similarly, reactions on X have showcased a blend of approval and criticism. Fans have taken to the platform to voice their thoughts, further emphasizing the polarized nature of the cover’s reception.
Conclusion
As Megadeth’s final album marks a significant moment in the band’s legacy, the cover of “Ride the Lightning” has become a focal point for discussions among fans. While some appreciate the homage to the past and the tribute to Metallica, others feel that the cover lacks originality. Regardless of individual opinions, it is evident that this rendition has sparked meaningful conversations about the intersections of musical history and personal evolution within the metal genre.
FAQs
Why did Megadeth cover “Ride the Lightning”?
Dave Mustaine described the cover as a way to “complete the circle,” paying respects to the band that helped launch his songwriting career.
How have fans reacted to the cover?
Fans’ reactions have been mixed, with some praising it as a tribute and others criticizing it for being too similar to the original.
What is the significance of “Ride the Lightning” for Dave Mustaine?
“Ride the Lightning” is significant for Mustaine as it represents the beginning of his songwriting journey, making the cover a poignant choice for the band’s last album.
