The Unforeseen Legacy of “Without You” by Badfinger

When Pete Ham and Tom Evans of Badfinger wrote “Without You” in 1970, they had little inkling that the song would eventually become an international sensation. Initially, both songwriters viewed the track as lacking potential, and tragically, neither would live to witness its remarkable success.

Tragic Endings

Ham’s life ended in suicide in 1975, five years after the song’s release on Badfinger’s album No Dice. Evans followed suit in 1983, also taking his own life. The financial turmoil surrounding the band, largely due to their manager Stan Polley’s mismanagement, significantly contributed to their despair. Polley had signed them to a contract with Warner Bros. in the early ’70s that left the majority of the band’s earnings in his hands. A subsequent lawsuit by Warner against Polley led to his disappearance, leaving Badfinger with little support and no financial security.

Ham’s Final Words

In a heartbreaking note, Ham expressed his disillusionment, stating, “I will not be allowed to love and trust everybody. This is better. Pete. PS Stan Polley is a soulless bastard. I will take him with me.” Evans also faced conflict over financial issues, which culminated in a bitter argument with bandmate Joey Molland regarding royalties for “Without You,” leading to his tragic decision to end his life.

The Song’s Rise to Fame

Despite the struggles faced by its creators, “Without You” found its way into the spotlight thanks to Harry Nilsson, who released a cover of the song in 1971. Interestingly, Nilsson initially mistook the song for a Beatles track when he heard it at a party. His interpretation brought its own set of challenges; producer Richard Perry had to convince Nilsson to embrace the rhythm section despite the artist’s reservations about the song’s quality.

Nilsson’s Interpretation

Nilsson’s rendition ultimately took on a more somber tone, with orchestral flourishes enhancing its emotional weight. Featuring renowned musicians such as Klaus Voormann, Jim Keltner, and Gary Wright, Nilsson’s version captured the essence of the song while infusing it with a distinct sound reminiscent of The Beatles. The gamble paid off when Nilsson’s cover soared to No. 1 in both the U.S. and U.K., earning him a Grammy for Best Male Pop Vocal Performance.

Recognition from Badfinger

For Badfinger, Nilsson’s success was a watershed moment. Evans remarked in 1972, “No one had recorded any of our songs until then. It had been our ambition to write songs other people would record. It’s one of the most exciting things that has happened.”

The Song’s Continued Impact

Years later, in 1994, “Without You” experienced a resurgence through Mariah Carey. At that point, Carey had already established herself as a leading vocalist and songwriter, but she chose to cover the song for her third album, Music Box.

Carey’s Connection to the Song

Carey, still in her early 20s, had a diverse musical background, which may have influenced her decision to cover “Without You.” In an interview, she elaborated on her eclectic musical tastes, mentioning her fondness for gospel music, rap, and classic soul. Ultimately, she stated, “I heard that song in a restaurant and just knew it would be a huge international hit.”

Commercial Success

Carey’s version, which closely followed Nilsson’s arrangement but showcased her powerful vocal style, was released as a single shortly after Nilsson’s passing. It achieved remarkable success, becoming her first No. 1 hit in the U.K. and reaching the top of the charts in several European countries, solidifying “Without You” as a timeless classic.

Conclusion

The journey of “Without You” from its unassuming beginnings with Badfinger to its monumental success through covers by Harry Nilsson and Mariah Carey is a poignant reminder of the unpredictability of music and legacy. While Ham and Evans faced tragic endings, their creation continues to resonate with audiences worldwide, illustrating the enduring power of songwriting and the complex tapestry of fame.

FAQs

Who originally wrote “Without You”?

“Without You” was written by Pete Ham and Tom Evans of the band Badfinger in 1970.

What made Harry Nilsson’s version successful?

Harry Nilsson’s cover of “Without You” was successful due to its somber arrangement and orchestral elements, which resonated with audiences. It reached No. 1 in both the U.S. and U.K.

How did Mariah Carey contribute to the song’s legacy?

Mariah Carey covered “Without You” in 1994, achieving significant commercial success and introducing the song to a new generation, further solidifying its status as a classic.

What were the circumstances surrounding the deaths of Pete Ham and Tom Evans?

Both Ham and Evans faced financial turmoil and struggles with their management, which contributed to their tragic decisions to end their lives.