The Backing Tracks Debate in Modern Rock and Metal

One of the most contentious discussions in contemporary rock and metal circles revolves around the use of backing tracks during live performances. Recently, Shinedown’s guitarist Zach Myers weighed in on this topic during an interview with American Musical Supply, referencing a legendary rock band to illustrate his point about the acceptability of backing tracks.

Insights from Zach Myers

Myers on Backing Tracks

During his chat with AMS’ Ryan Dacey at the Welcome to Rockville festival, Myers covered various subjects, from his signature PRS guitar to the intricacies of crafting Shinedown’s setlists and his experiences as a father. He began by discussing Shinedown’s decision to move away from click tracks, stating, “There’s some songs, obviously, we still do ‘cause we run string tracks and things like that.”

Dacey remarked on the necessity of these tracks for reproducing the studio sound in a live setting, to which Myers enthusiastically agreed. He expressed frustration with the current trend among some bands to boast about not using backing tracks, saying, “Like, shut up, dude! Who cares? Queen did it, so shut up.” Myers emphasized that audiences want to experience the symphonic elements of songs like “Second Chance,” and mentioned that while they may use backing for strings, the core instruments are played live.

Clarifying Misconceptions

Myers clarified that while some bands may over-rely on tracks, Shinedown strives to keep the essence of live music intact. He stated, “If you’re running vocals and you’re running guitars and you’re not playing things, that’s… yeah. I think people think that when you run tracks, that’s what you’re doing.” He reassured fans that unless they hear specific orchestral components, everything else is performed by the band members themselves.

Myers’ Previous Commentary

Earlier Views on the Issue

In a prior discussion on The Jeremy White Show, Myers reiterated his stance on backing tracks, emphasizing that although Shinedown uses some tracks, they are not a band that heavily relies on them. He acknowledged the valid criticisms regarding artists who mime or don’t perform live solos, asserting, “If there’s a guitar solo going on and the guy’s not soloing, dude, that’s bullshit.”

However, he also pointed out the practical reasons behind using tracks, such as avoiding hiring extra musicians and maintaining the band’s dynamic. Myers referenced industry peers who have used backing tracks, noting that bands like Def Leppard and Queen were pioneers in this practice. He challenged critics to experience a Shinedown show with the tracks muted and see if they could tell the difference.

What’s New with Shinedown?

This year, Shinedown released new singles, “Dance, Kid, Dance” and “Three Six Five,” and they launched their 2025 tour in grand style. Notably, they performed alongside guitarist Rickey Medlocke and vocalist Johnny Van Zant for a rendition of Lynyrd Skynyrd’s “Simple Man,” highlighting their commitment to delivering memorable live experiences.

The Broader Backing Tracks Discussion

The debate surrounding backing tracks continues to elicit strong opinions from artists and fans alike. Sebastian Bach expressed concerns in 2021 about the authenticity of performances that rely heavily on pre-recorded elements, stating, “Real musicians hit your heart way more hard than guys miming to a tape.” Conversely, Nikki Sixx of Mötley Crüe defended the use of technology in live performances, emphasizing its role in enhancing sound without hiding its usage. Other bands, like Mudvayne, have criticized the prevalence of backing tracks, with frontman Chad Gray labeling it an “epidemic” while advocating for a more honest live sound.

Conclusion

The use of backing tracks in live performances remains a divisive issue within the rock and metal communities. While some artists embrace the technology as a tool to enhance their sound, others fear it undermines the authenticity of live music. As discussions continue and more artists share their perspectives, the conversation surrounding this topic is likely to evolve, reflecting the changing landscape of live performances in the modern music industry.

FAQs

What are backing tracks?

Backing tracks are pre-recorded audio elements used during live performances to enhance the overall sound, often including additional instruments or vocal harmonies that the live band cannot replicate on stage.

Why do some bands use backing tracks?

Many bands use backing tracks to recreate complex studio sounds, fill out their live performances, and provide a richer audio experience for the audience without the need for additional musicians.

Are backing tracks a sign of a lack of talent?

This is a matter of opinion. Some fans and artists believe that heavy reliance on backing tracks can detract from a band’s authenticity, while others see it as a legitimate tool to enhance live performances.

Which famous bands have used backing tracks?

Several well-known bands, including Queen, Def Leppard, and Mötley Crüe, have incorporated backing tracks into their live shows to enhance their performances.

What do critics say about the use of backing tracks?

Critics often argue that backing tracks can lead to inauthentic performances, particularly if musicians are not playing their instruments live or if they are miming to pre-recorded vocals. However, others contend that when used correctly, backing tracks can improve the overall concert experience.