Tim McGraw’s Bold Stand for “Indian Outlaw”

Before becoming one of country music’s biggest stars, Tim McGraw faced significant resistance from his record label over a song they deemed too risky. This song, “Indian Outlaw,” would ultimately become a pivotal part of his career, showcasing his willingness to take risks.

The Song Nobody Wanted

In a recent appearance on The Tim Ferriss Show, McGraw reflected on his struggle to include “Indian Outlaw” in his 1993 self-titled debut album. Despite his enthusiasm, the label was not on board.

“The label didn’t like it,” he recounted, noting that only his producer, Byron Gallimore, supported his vision for the track. Label executives warned him that the song would likely not receive radio play and could jeopardize his credibility in the industry. However, McGraw had already witnessed the song’s potential firsthand.

After experiencing a live performance by songwriters Tommy Barnes and Max D. Barnes in Nashville, he began to incorporate it into his sets at honky-tonks and clubs across the nation. The audience response was overwhelmingly positive, often prompting him to perform the song multiple times in a single night.

Despite the growing excitement from fans, McGraw lacked the influence needed to override the label’s decision, and “Indian Outlaw” was excluded from his debut record.

A Career Gamble

When it was time to record his second album, Not a Moment Too Soon, McGraw was determined to change the narrative. He recognized the potential impact of “Indian Outlaw,” stating, “I felt like this is either going to work in a huge way, or it’s going to ruin my career forever.” Fortunately for McGraw, the gamble paid off.

Upon its release, “Indian Outlaw” not only became his first Top 10 hit but also achieved platinum status. McGraw credits the release of this song, followed by “Don’t Take the Girl,” as the catalyst that truly launched his career. “I’ll forever believe that the combination of those two songs is what set my career in motion,” he asserted.

The Controversy That Followed

While “Indian Outlaw” brought McGraw success, it also stirred controversy. The song faced criticism for perpetuating Native American stereotypes, a concern that McGraw acknowledges and takes seriously. Over the years, he has engaged with Native American leaders to address these issues, recognizing that opinions on the song vary widely.

Interestingly, during performances at Native American-owned casinos, McGraw often offers to omit the song from his setlist. However, he reports that most of the time, the venues request he include it, indicating its popularity among audiences.

Reflecting on the journey, McGraw views “Indian Outlaw” as a significant risk that could have had a very different outcome. Instead, it became a defining moment in his career, a testament to his belief in himself and his music.

Conclusion

Tim McGraw’s experience with “Indian Outlaw” illustrates the complexities of navigating artistic integrity and commercial viability in the music industry. His willingness to stand by his vision ultimately led to one of his most successful songs, shaping the trajectory of his career and inviting important conversations about representation in music.

FAQs

Why was “Indian Outlaw” controversial?

The song faced backlash for leaning into Native American stereotypes, raising concerns about cultural appropriation and representation.

What was the outcome of releasing “Indian Outlaw”?

“Indian Outlaw” became Tim McGraw’s first Top 10 hit and achieved platinum status, significantly contributing to his career momentum.

Did Tim McGraw always believe in the song’s potential?

Yes, McGraw recognized the song’s potential early on, despite the label’s skepticism, and eventually fought for its inclusion in his second album.

How did audiences react to “Indian Outlaw”?

Audiences embraced the song, often requesting it multiple times during live performances, which indicated its popularity and appeal.

What steps has Tim McGraw taken regarding the song’s criticism?

McGraw has met with Native American leaders to discuss concerns about the song and often offers to leave it out of his setlist when performing at Native American-owned venues.